5785 Results for “FC 26 monedas Visité Buyfc26coins.com. Ofertas exclusivas y entrega relámpago. ¡Fantástico!.6AWm”
-
Video
The End of Laissez-Faire?
Mar 1, 2023
Jamee Moudud discusses the circular relationship of law, politics, and economics.
-
Article
Navigating the Turning Point
Mar 16, 2011
From MIT to IMF
-
Video
What Role Should Economists Play in Climate Policy?
May 30, 2018
Economist James K. Boyce argues that the distribution of carbon tax revenue is just as important as the price itself
-
Partnership
Cambridge-INET Institute
Supporting doctoral research through granting PhDs, appointing post-doctoral fellowships, hosting leading international economists, sponsoring major conferences and providing seed funding for cutting-edge research projects.
-
News
INET Hiring Postdoctoral Fellows
Nov 18, 2012
The Institute for New Economic Thinking has openings for 2-4 Postdoctoral Fellows in New York City.
-
News
Sen Warns of Europe’s Well-Meaning Mistakes
May 23, 2012
If proof were needed of the maxim that the road to hell is paved with good intentions, the economic crisis in Europe provides it
-
Video
Diversity Is Development
Jul 27, 2022
INET grantee Vamsi Vakulabharanam describes his work to gather parallel social threads—such as class, caste, gender and religion—to better understand the mechanisms of inequality in India, and why this can lead to better outcomes around the world.
-
Video
Can Economics Save the Environment?
Oct 7, 2020
We need to get smarter about how we think about climate change and its impacts.
-
Collection
Is Green Growth Possible?
Economists debate whether catastrophic global warming can be stopped while maintaining current levels of economic growth. Enno Schröder, Servaas Storm, Gregor Semieniuk, Lance Taylor, and Armon Rezai find there is a tradeoff between growth and decarbonization, while Michael Grubb responds with more optimism.
-
News
New Book: Inequality and Inclusive Growth in Rich Countries
Sep 12, 2018
INET Oxford’s Brian Nolan writes on his new book for VoxEU
-
Video
‘Stratification’ Theory Tackles the Racial Blindspots of Orthodox Economics
Nov 2, 2016
Economist Darrick Hamilton and Institute President Rob Johnson discuss “stratification economics”, which addresses the failure of orthodox economics to see, explain and point to remedies for persistent racial inequality.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperFinance and Growth: When Credit Helps, and When it Hinders
Apr 2012
The financial sector can support growth but it can also cause crisis. The present crisis has exposedgaps in economists’ understanding of this dual potential.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperSocial Interaction Models and Keynes' Macroeconomics
Apr 2015
The central concepts of Keynes’ macroeconomic theories concerning the behavior of labor markets, aggregate demand, and asset pricing can be formulated as special cases of a general social interaction model.
-
Working Paper
Working Paper SeriesHousehold Income, Demand, and Saving: Deriving Macro Data with Micro Data Concepts
Mar 2015
We develop adjustments to align the NIPA measures of key household flows with cash flow concepts that better reflect household budgets and demand.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperEndogenising Uncertainty
Apr 2013
Uncertainty is an unavoidable feature of economic life, although we may cope with it sometimes by ignoring it. Institutions, conventions and behaviour are all conditioned by uncertainty, and they in turn condition uncertainty in a reflexive manner.
-
Site Pages
Digital Style Guide
-
Working Paper
Working Paper SeriesSocial Stability and Resource Allocation within Business Groups
Aug 2018
Using datasets on transactions within business groups and social sentiment in China, I show that state-owned enterprises (SOEs) use internal funds to address social unrest, complying with the government’s political goals.
-
Collection
Cryptocurrency in Context
Cryptocurrency is one of the hottest topics in finance, yet it is often misunderstood, both by the general public and self-proclaimed “experts.” In this collection, members of the INET community offer a broader look at the economics of cryptocurrency, and money itself.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperFrom the Prevailing Paradigm to the Qualitative Expectations Hypothesis
Oct 2017
In the paper that we present this afternoon, Soren Johansen, Anders Rahbek, Morten Tabor, and I introduce the Qualitative Expectations Hypothesis (QEH) as a new approach to modeling macroeconomic and financial outcomes.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperSecular Demand Stagnation in the 21st Century U.S. Economy
Dec 2017
The concern that an economy could experience persistent, and in some sense unusual, weakness goes back to Keynes’s General Theory and led Alvin Hansen to coin the term “secular stagnation.”
-
Working Paper
Conference paperIrreducible Uncertainty and its Implications: A Narrative Action Theory for Economics.
Apr 2013
At the heart of economics is a theory of action. It reflects views about how human beings make economic decisions and leads to an analysis of aggregate consequences.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperThe State, the Market and the Rule of Law
Apr 2013
State and market are often depicted as distinct, even antagonistic. Markets appear as natural products of spontaneous ordering; states as leviathans that if left untamed will distort, if not destroy markets’ natural state.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperInequality: A Neuroscience Perspective
Apr 2015
It is impossible to ignore material inequality. Wealth, and the goods that come with it, are accumulating at the top of society while others seem to be struggling in the middle and bottom.
-
Person
Collin Constantine
Coordinator, YSI Economic Development Working Group Kingston University Collin Constantine is a Ph.D. Candidate in Economics at Kingston University and works on Economic Development & Growth, Open Economy Macroeconomics, Distribution and Political Economy. -
Person
Johannes Tiemer
Coordinator of YSI Complexity Economics Working Group PhD Candidate, University of Duisburg-Essen Interested in macro views on money, society, institutions and their interaction. On the methodological side, he is into agent-based modelling, complexity, networks, econometrics and programming. -
Conference Session
What Must Be Done to Avert Climate Catastrophe?
Sep 21, 2021 | 01:00—02:00
Are existing institutions up to the task? Is the nation-state an obstacle, and if so how do we overcome it? What would alternatives look like, and how would we realize them?
-
Working Paper
Working Paper SeriesInflation? It’s Import Prices and the Labor Share!
Jan 2021
Recognizing that inflation of the value of output and its costs of production must be equal, we focus on a cost-based macroeconomic structuralist approach in contrast to micro-oriented monetarist analysis.
-
Video
Behavioral Economics: The Next Generation
Feb 27, 2019
To understand behavior and choice, we need to borrow from not just cognitive science but also sociology.
-
Video
The New Economic Giants
Dec 26, 2018
Eisuke Sakakibara: China and India will become titans on the world stage
-
Conference Session
New Nationalist Challenges to Globalization: The Good, Bad, and Ugly
Oct 13, 2016 | 06:00—07:30
A conversation with Robert Johnson, President of the Institute for New Economic Thinking, former Managing Director for Soros Fund Management and former Chief Economist of the US Senate Banking Committee.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperNarrative in Teaching Economics
Apr 2014
Economics has advanced an enormous distance from the Walrasian paradigm and the Neoclassical synthesis. However, undergraduate curriculums continue to heavily favour these views of what economics is and what tools it provides for understanding contemporarypublic problems.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperThe Contingent Expectations Hypothesis: Rationality and Contingent Knowledge in Macroeconomics and Finance Theory
Apr 2013
For macroeconomists, an individual is rational if she uses her understanding of the way the economy works in making decisions that do not conflict with her objectives.
-
Site Pages
M–P
-
Working Paper
Working PaperThe Anatomy of Cyber Risk
May 2023
Does cyber risk exposure, as opposed to actual incidents, affect firm outcomes?
-
Working Paper
Working Paper SeriesThe Changing Shape of the World Automobile Industry: A Multilayer Network Analysis of International Trade in Components and Parts
Jan 2022
The pandemic and electrification are shaking the foundations of the auto industry
-
Working Paper
Working Paper SeriesEmployment Mobility and the Belated Emergence of the Black Middle Class
Jan 2021
“Build back” means restoring the government and business investments in the productive capabilities of the U.S. labor force that created a growing middle class in the three decades after World War II
-
Video
Change in the Economics Profession Can Come From the Outside
Aug 7, 2019
Progressive movements can and should push for pluralism in economics
-
Working Paper
Conference paperWhy Observation of the Behaviour of Human Actors and How They Combine Within the Economy, is an Important Next Step.
Oct 2017
One might think of the satisfied consensus reigning in macroeconomics before the financial crisis (and still relatively entrenched) as evidence of “Groupthink” in a “Divided State”
-
Working Paper
Working Paper SeriesThe Qualitative Expectations Hypothesis
Jun 2017
Model Ambiguity, Consistent Representations of Market Forecasts, and Sentiment
-
Working Paper
Grantee paperPrincipled Policymaking in an Uncertain World
Jun 2012
Revised text of a presentation at the Conference on Microfoundations for Modern Macroeconomics, Columbia University, November 2010. I would like to thank Amar Bhidé, Roman Frydman, and Andy Haldane for helpful comments, and the Institute for New Economic Thinking for research support.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperGeorge Soros: The Living History of the Last 30 years
Apr 2010
Economic theory has modeled itself on theoretical physics. It has sought to establish timelessly valid laws that govern economic behavior and can be used reversibly both to explain and to predict events.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperInequality and Employment
Apr 2012
“Natural rate theory” has dominated interpretations of economic trends and policy prescriptions over many decades. European-type welfare state institution were claimed to cause a compressed wage distribution that distorts otherwise well functioning labor markets.
-
Video
Learn the Language of Power
Oct 30, 2019
Economists make what we do seem complicated, says Ha-Joon Chang. It’s not.
-
Video
A Society Designed to Incentivize Criminal Behavior at the Highest Level
Aug 11, 2021
Matt Stoller, Director of Research at the American Economic Liberties Project and author of Goliath: The 100-Year War Between Monopoly Power and Democracy, talks about the many ways in which the US economic system has become rigged to favor the richest.
-
Working Paper
Working Paper SeriesPayment vs. Funding: The Law of Reflux for Today
Feb 2020
The central bank today is not just the government’s bank, but also a bankers’ bank, a truly hybrid institution
-
Video
What is Feminist Economics?
Nov 18, 2020
“All of us, if we get old enough, need to be taken care of.”
-
Working Paper
Conference paper“Come forth into the light of things”: William Wordsworth’s Human Challenge to Economic Thinking
Oct 2017
When priests and princes lost their monopoly over the big questions of human existence over the course of the Enlightenment, philosophers, poets, and ordinary people struggled to find out the answers on their own.
-
Conference Session
Taking the Con Out of Economics? The Limits of Negative Darwinism
Oct 22, 2017 | 12:00
What Do Citations Actually Measure in Economics and How Should Economic Journals and Department Review Committees Use This Data?
-
Working Paper
Conference paperPrecarious Condition: A Challenge For New Forms Of Struggle
Feb 2015
This text is part of a research project still in working progress that collects different contributions by the author and rewrite and reanalyse some reflections, already present, in a different form, in some publications:
-
Conference Session
Managing the Global Commons: Growth, Inequality, and New Thinking for Sustainable Economics
Apr 13, 2012 | 03:45—05:35
How can we distribute growth globally when the developed world needs growth to emerge from debt overhangs and inequality between nations is still quite formidable?
-
Conference Session
The Challenge of De-leveraging and Overhangs of Debt I : Inflation and Austerity
Apr 12, 2012 | 03:45—05:55
After an era of vigorous expansion a downturn can reveal a large stock of debt relative to the economy’s capacity to service it.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperRenminbi Internationalization: Tempest in a Teapot?
Apr 2013
Internationalization of the renminbi is a stated goal of the Chinese government, its brief flirtation with Special Drawing Rights and an Asian Currency Unit notwithstanding. Chinese officials understand that a dollar-centric international monetary and financial system is a mixedblessing.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperProfits Without Prosperity: How Stock Buybacks Manipulate the Market, and Leave Most Americans Worse Off
Apr 2014
Five years after the end of the Great Recession, corporate profits are high and the stock market is booming. Yet most Americans are not sharing in the apparent prosperity.
-
Working Paper
Working Paper SeriesWealth Concentration, Income Distribution, and Alternatives for the USA
Sep 2015
US household wealth concentration is not likely to decline in response to fiscal interventions alone.
-
Video
What is Work?
Jun 10, 2020
What counts as work and what doesn’t?
-
Article
German Court decision: Legal authority and deep power implications
Feb 26, 2014
Who wields supreme power over the ECB? This column analyses the recent ruling by the German Constitutional Court that the ECB cannot act as lender of last resort. Although seemingly couched by the referral of this decision to the European Court of Justice, this is a bid for power and the return to the pre-crisis paradigm of ‘ultra posse nemo obligatur’.
-
Article
The Efficiency of Markets
Sep 30, 2015
A student of microeconomics learns that any competitive equilibrium leads to a Pareto efficient outcome (First Fundamental Theorem of Welfare Economics). What do we mean by the efficiency or inefficiency of markets?
-
Article
Mr. Market's Rorschach Test
May 7, 2011
Currencies or Commodities?
-
News
China Needs Slower, Better Growth
Aug 8, 2010
Is China growing too fast?
-
Working Paper
Working Paper SeriesExecutive compensation in Europe: Realized gains from stock-based pay
Sep 2018
This paper adds to the empirical evidence on the extent to which stock-based pay incentivizes and rewards European corporate executives. It shows that the actual realized gains (that is, take-home compensation) from stock-based pay of CEOs in European publicly-listed firms may be underestimated by the use of “estimated fair value” measures. The paper also documents the heterogeneity among countries in terms of the levels and components of CEO take-home pay. We base our work on a sample of 301 large, publicly-traded companies listed in the S&P Europe 350 index from 11 EU countries: Belgium, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Netherlands, Spain, Sweden and United Kingdom for the fiscal year 2015. Through analyzing companies’ annual reports, we have hand-collected data on various elements of compensation of the company’s CEO in 2015, including the gains that executives realize from stock-based pay. We document that on average half of the total compensation of the European CEOs in our sample is stock-based, measured by actual realized gains, with large differences among countries. Although in some European countries the majority of total compensation is stock-based, the proportions are still well below those that prevail in the
-
News
Deutschlandfunk features Edward A. Tenenbaum and the Deutschmark
Jul 24, 2025
Deutschlandfunk
-
Video
Our Own Worst Enemy
Dec 13, 2021
Tom Nichols, Professor of National Security Affairs, US Naval War College, columnist for USA Today, and contributing writer at The Atlantic, discusses his new book, Our Own Worst Enemy: The Assault from within on Modern Democracy, and how a decline in civic virtue has generated a dangerous illiberalism.
-
Video
The Obscene Obstacles to Global Vaccine Distribution
Aug 6, 2021
Lori Wallach, of Public Citizen’s Global Trade Watch, and Jayati Ghosh, economics professor at UMass Amherst, discuss how first world countries are protecting pharma companies’ exorbitant profits, at the expense of vaccinating people living in the Global South and thereby also endangering everyone in the world.
-
Working Paper
Working Paper SeriesBig Tech Acquisitions and the Potential Competition Doctrine: The Case of Facebook
Oct 2019
How antitrust law is ill-equipped to address tech mergers
-
Working Paper
Working Paper SeriesAmerican Gothic: How Chicago Economics Distorts “Consumer Welfare” in Antitrust
Jul 2019
The Chicago School has long used bankrupt assumptions to strangle antitrust policy.
-
Collection
2008: A Retrospective on the Financial Crisis
Before 2008, mainstream economics thought a global economic crisis on the scale of the Great Depression was impossible. Then Lehman Brothers declared bankruptcy. A decade later, INET looks back at the causes of the global financial crisis, and what policymakers—and economists—must change to prevent another one.
-
News
Intellectual Property Watch: Patents Without Examination
Apr 30, 2018
INET Senior Economist Arjun Jayadev and Dean Baker explore the patent system of Brazil, and its implications for developing countries.
-
Research Program News
BBC World Service Interviews CGET Commissioners Rob Johnson and Winnie Byanyima
Nov 10, 2017
Why the solution to global inequality may actually be the revival of old school policies such as public education and organised labour rights.
-
Research Program News
BBC World Service Interviews CGET Commissioners Rob Johnson and Winnie Byanyima
Nov 10, 2017
Why the solution to global inequality may actually be the revival of old school policies such as public education and organised labour rights.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperReal vs. Imagined Financial Markets The Regulatory Challenge
Apr 2012
We have grown accustomed to regulating financial markets based on imagined, not real markets. Real markets are shaped by and co-evolve with institutional arrangements within two fundamental constraints: Imperfect knowledge and the threat of illiquidity.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperAusteritarianism in Europe: What Options for Resistance?
Apr 2015
In much of Europe, the social rights and social protections won in the first post-war decades, by labour movements in particular, have subsequently been seriously eroded, and are further threatened by neoliberal austerity.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperRationality and the Meese and Rogoff Exchange-Rate-Disconnect Puzzle: Learning vs. Contingent Knowledge
Apr 2013
There is much anecdotal evidence in the popular media, backed up by survey research, that participants in currency markets pay close attention to fundamental economic variables in forming their forecasts of future exchange rates.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperIf Not Now, When? Financial Reform Must Not Await Another Crisis
Apr 2013
In the first ten chapters of our book, The Bankers’ New Clothes: What’s Wrong with Banking and What to Do about It, we discuss banking and the economics of funding as it applies to banks.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperSevering the Innovation-Inequality Link: Distribution Sensitive Science, Technology and Innovation Policies in Developed Nations
Apr 2015
Innovation is essential to economic growth. However, it appears that the ways in which we pursue innovation policies have aggravated inequality. Inequality is an increasingly contentious political issue in both wealthy and emerging economies.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperReviving Debate In Economics: Motivations and Methods of the International Student Movement
Apr 2015
In the past three years, students around the world have turned the heat of scrutiny onto our economics departments. Our call is strikingly uniform across our diverse cultures and languages: we want critical debate back in the economics curriculum.
-
Video
How Kids Are Left Behind
May 10, 2023
What’s really causing inequality in opportunities and outcomes for kids?
-
Video
Sellers Inflation
Oct 18, 2023
Is inflation just a number game or does it hold deeper societal implications?
-
Video
How Do We Create the Financial Conditions for a Green New Deal?
Nov 3, 2021
Political economist, author, and public speaker Ann Pettifor talks about her latest book, The Case for a Green New Deal, which not only lays out the urgency for such a deal, but also proposes a roadmap for both national and global financial reform to make it possible.
-
Video
Innovation Needs Inventors
Jun 17, 2020
By not addressing inclusivity, we are losing entire generations of new minds.
-
News
Servaas Storm Featured in Frontline
Mar 4, 2019
Servaas Storm’s INET research is featured in the Indian news magazine Frontline
-
Working Paper
Working Paper SeriesVeiled Repression: Mainstream Economics, Capital Theory, and the Distributions of Income and Wealth
Dec 2015
The Cambridge UK vs USA capital theory debates of the 1960s showed that the workhorse mainstream growth model relies on unsustainable assumptions. Its standard interpretation is not consistent with the last four decades of data.
-
Working Paper
Grantee paperClassical Competition and Freedom of Contract in American Laissez Faire Constitutionalism
Jun 2014
It is impossible to tell the history of American antitrust law and economics during the so-called formative era (1890- 1915) without a preliminary understanding of the economic rationale underlying that major phase of American constitutional law commonly called laissez faire constitutionalism, or Lochner era.
-
Video
Challenging the Foundation
Apr 11, 2012
George Soros, Axel Leijonhufvud and Perry Mehrling in Berlin, Germany (2012).
-
Conference Session
The Challenge of De-Leveraging and Debt Overhangs II : The Politics and Economics of Restructuring
Apr 12, 2012 | 06:15—08:05
When the very fabric of society is threatened by prolonged austerity or a financial sector collapse, a deliberate re-structuring of debt may be necessary to restore the hopes of renewed prosperity.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperNew Metrics for Economic Complexity: Measuring the Intangible Growth Potential of Countries
Apr 2013
In this paper we provide a summary and a guide to the literature for a new line of research which goes under the name of Economic Complexity and is partly performed incollaboration with INET.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperEconomics and the Powerful: Faulty Analysis, Economic Advice, and the Imperatives of Power
Apr 2013
“Look! Up there in the sky! What is it? Is it a plane? Is it a bird?” No, it’s a distraction from the robbery that is taking place in broad daylight on the ground.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperRationality in the Present-Value Model of Stock Prices: Fundamentals, Psychology, and Structural Change
Apr 2013
The present-value model of stock prices is a workhorse in financial economics. The model relates today’s price of a stock (or a basket of stocks) to the market’s forecasts of next-period’s price and dividend, appropriately discounted.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperWho should do R and who should do D?
Apr 2014
This article studies the reasons for the under-investment in research vs. development in the decentralized equilibrium and argues that this bias provides a micro-foundation for the government direct involvement in conducting applied research rather than just financing it.
-
Working Paper
Working paperLaid Low: The IMF, The Eurozone and the First Rescue of Greece
Apr 2015
As Greece descended into a financial maelstrom in the spring of 2010, a small group of staffers at the International Monetary Fund (IMF) held top-secret talks with officials from the German and French finance ministries to discuss the idea of restructuring Greece’s debt.
-
Video
The Big Myth of Market Fundamentalism
Mar 22, 2023
Historians Naomi Oreskes (Harvard University) and Erik Conway (Caltech) talk to Rob about their just released book, The Big Myth: How American Business Taught Us to Loathe Government and Love the Free Market.
-
Person
Danilo Spinola
Chairman, YSI Community Board Senior Lecturer, Birmingham City Business School Spinola’s academic works is focused on the challenges of economic development in a structuralist framework with a focus on Innovation, Structural Change, and Economic Complexity. He is furthermore interested in developing alternative economic theories in the Keynesian and Evolutionary traditions. -
Webinars and Events
Research in Action Workshop 2026
ConferenceThe Science of Critical Minerals and the Realigning Global Order
Apr 27–28, 2026
The Institute for New Economic Thinking (INET) and the Cambridge Central Asia Forum, University of Cambridge, in partnership with the University of Sussex, UK, are organizing the Research in Action Workshop 2026: The Science of Critical Minerals and the Realigning Global Order, on 27–28 April 2026 at the University of Cambridge.
-
Video
What Happens When Economics Doesn’t Reflect the Real World?
Jan 15, 2020
Anwar Shaikh talks about the shortcomings of neoclassical economics and alternative frameworks
-
Video
Why We Should Decriminalize Sex Work
Mar 27, 2019
Stigmatizing and relegating an activity to the shadows doesn’t improve anyone’s welfare
-
News
The Edinburgh Reporter: Call for green investment to transform Scotland’s economy
Oct 23, 2017
INET Chairman Adair Turner and Grantee Mariana Mazzucato comment on the Friends of the Earth Scotland event and a green economic transition.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperRevitalizing Global Economic and Financial Cooperation: Observations on the Global Financial Architecture
Apr 2010
Since the outbreak of the Asian financial crisis more than a decade ago, world leaders have been searching for ways to make the global financial system more resilient, less crisis-prone, and better able to play its essential role in supporting broadly-shared growth.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperWhat Kind of Theory to Guide Reform and Restructuring of the Financial and Non-Financial Sectors?
Apr 2010
The purpose of the paper is to argue for attention to be paid, not only to choice of theory, but also to choice of theoretical approach, in order to address issues posed by the crisis.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperNew Theories to Underpin Financial Reform
Apr 2010
As Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff remind us in the title of their book, This Time is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly, financial crises are nothing new (Reinhart and Rogoff (2009)). However, they often come as a surprise to many people because in most countries they appear only periodically.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperInterpreting the Great Depression: Hayek versus Keynes
Apr 2010
This is not intended to be a purely historical paper. I am interested in the light the Keynesian and Hayekian interpretations of the Great Depression throw on the causes of the Great Recession of 2007-9 and in the policy relevance of the two positions to the management of today’s globalizing economy.
-
Working Paper
Conference paperA New Rational Expectations Hypothesis: What Can Economists Really Know About the Future?
Apr 2015
John Muth proposed the Rational Expectations Hypothesis (REH) to represent how the market (an aggregate of its participants) understands and forecasts outcomes. REH imposes internal consistency between the market’s forecasts and “the relevant economic theory” (Muth 1961, p. 316).